
Playtest report preview
Fantasy Blacksmith SimulatorWhat streamers ran into on Twitch
Blacksmith simulator where you forge weapons and armor, craft jewelry, and enchant gear, solo or co-op.
We listened to 8 Twitch streams of Fantasy Blacksmith Simulator (7h 22m in total). The problem that came up most: early upgrades cost too much and leave player broke, in 3 of 8 streams.
8 Twitch streams · 7h 22m analysed · French, English, Spanish · analysed in the week of 19 Oct 2026 · Steam page
- Problems
- 60
- Ideas
- 6
- Highlights
- 15
Each problem, idea and highlight counts once, however often it came up. The timeline counts every moment: 165 in all.
Read what they actually saidFull report with quotes and VOD links · $49Events and lists
Featured in
Where the moments happened
Grey bars show when the streamer was talking. Each mark is one reported moment; select a type below to hide or show it.
- Stream 1, 1h analysed: 13 problems, 3 suggestions or comparisons, 5 highlights.
- Stream 2, 49 min analysed: 5 problems.
- Stream 3, 45 min analysed: 26 problems, 1 suggestion or comparison, 5 highlights.
- Stream 4, 48 min analysed: 33 problems, 4 suggestions or comparisons, 6 highlights.
- Stream 5, 1h analysed: 25 problems, 3 suggestions or comparisons, 2 highlights.
- Stream 6, 1h analysed: 6 problems, 2 highlights.
- Stream 7, 1h analysed: 15 problems, 2 suggestions or comparisons, 6 highlights.
- Stream 8, 1h analysed: 3 problems.
In the full report each item below has the streamers' own words and a ▶ link to that minute of the Twitch recording. The # is the item's number in that report. See what a full item looks like in the sample report
Problems (60)
Bugs, confusion, frustration and the moments players gave up. The ones most streams ran into come first.
- #32Frustration
early upgrades cost too much and leave player broke
3 of 8 streams · 3 moments
3 quotes + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #1Bugblocking
joining a friend's co-op session fails with connection error
2 of 8 streams · 5 moments
5 quotes + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #4Confusion
unclear where to store or display finished swords
2 of 8 streams · 6 moments
6 quotes + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #33Frustration
forge fires break out too often during crafting
2 of 8 streams · 8 moments
8 quotes + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #34Frustration
customer influx outpaces production and feels stressful
2 of 8 streams · 6 moments
6 quotes + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #35Frustration
sword handles must be bought and cannot be crafted
2 of 8 streams · 5 moments
5 quotes + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #36Frustration
display racks cannot be placed against or mounted on walls
2 of 8 streams · 3 moments
3 quotes + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #5Confusion
station activation requirements such as water are unclear
2 of 8 streams · 4 moments
4 quotes + ▶ timestamps in the full report
Show all 60 problemsShow fewer
- #6Confusion
recipe inputs and where to obtain them are unclear
2 of 8 streams · 4 moments
4 quotes + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #7Confusion
workstations break down and need repair without explanation
2 of 8 streams · 3 moments
3 quotes + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #37Frustration
customers repeatedly dirty the shop, cleanup becomes a chore
2 of 8 streams · 4 moments
4 quotes + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #38Frustration
inventory space runs out while gathering or crafting
2 of 8 streams · 2 moments
2 quotes + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #39Frustration
not enough money to buy crafting materials
2 of 8 streams · 2 moments
2 quotes + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #40Frustration
default camera sensitivity is too high at start
2 of 8 streams · 2 moments
2 quotes + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #2Bug
footprint cleaning objective does not complete
1 of 8 streams · 1 moment
1 quote + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #8Confusion
haggling cards are unexplained and prices feel random
1 of 8 streams · 3 moments
3 quotes + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #9Confusion
friends can join co-op only when the host picks private
1 of 8 streams · 3 moments
3 quotes + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #10Confusion
unclear that ore is clicked into the melting pot
1 of 8 streams · 1 moment
1 quote + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #41Frustration
no french language option in the demo
1 of 8 streams · 3 moments
3 quotes + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #42Frustration
crafting minigames feel like quick time events
1 of 8 streams · 2 moments
2 quotes + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #43Frustration
gold deposits give coins instead of gold material
1 of 8 streams · 2 moments
2 quotes + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #44Frustration
mining hit inside green zone counted as a miss
1 of 8 streams · 1 moment
1 quote + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #3Bug
dropped swords glitch or end up on the floor
1 of 8 streams · 2 moments
2 quotes + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #11Confusion
random shop fires and forge fire control are unexplained
1 of 8 streams · 3 moments
3 quotes + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #12Confusion
mine and quest locations are hard to find or reach
1 of 8 streams · 3 moments
3 quotes + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #13Confusion
tutorial objectives ignore current sword stock
1 of 8 streams · 2 moments
2 quotes + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #14Confusion
mining controls and minigame are not taught
1 of 8 streams · 2 moments
2 quotes + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #15Confusion
forging and sharpening steps are not explained
1 of 8 streams · 2 moments
2 quotes + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #16Confusion
trash and broken tools appear without a clear cause
1 of 8 streams · 2 moments
2 quotes + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #17Confusion
ledger sale marking is confusing
1 of 8 streams · 2 moments
2 quotes + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #18Confusion
easy to get lost in the mine tunnels
1 of 8 streams · 2 moments
2 quotes + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #19Confusion
goblin intruder looks odd and its role is unclear
1 of 8 streams · 2 moments
2 quotes + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #20Confusion
mining tools and materials are not explained
1 of 8 streams · 2 moments
2 quotes + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #21Confusion
no customers arrive after opening the shop
1 of 8 streams · 1 moment
1 quote + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #22Confusion
switching to another recipe is not obvious
1 of 8 streams · 1 moment
1 quote + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #23Confusion
tutorial delivers a lot of text at once
1 of 8 streams · 1 moment
1 quote + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #24Confusion
purpose of gathered flowers is unclear
1 of 8 streams · 1 moment
1 quote + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #25Confusion
cleaning tool is not obvious at the start
1 of 8 streams · 1 moment
1 quote + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #26Confusion
hard to tell which mine holds which ore
1 of 8 streams · 1 moment
1 quote + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #27Confusion
steel recipe and smelting not clearly introduced
1 of 8 streams · 1 moment
1 quote + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #28Confusion
customer wait limit is not shown
1 of 8 streams · 1 moment
1 quote + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #29Confusion
markers above townspeople are not explained
1 of 8 streams · 1 moment
1 quote + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #30Confusion
purpose of a purchased tool is unclear
1 of 8 streams · 1 moment
1 quote + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #31Confusion
tree regrowth timer is unclear
1 of 8 streams · 1 moment
1 quote + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #45Frustration
no way to display swords before the weapon rack unlocks
1 of 8 streams · 3 moments
3 quotes + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #46Frustration
batch size does not match rack capacity
1 of 8 streams · 3 moments
3 quotes + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #47Frustration
serving requires holding swords and customers take every sword held
1 of 8 streams · 2 moments
2 quotes + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #48Frustration
pouring and carrying molten iron feels clunky
1 of 8 streams · 2 moments
2 quotes + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #49Frustration
footprint cleaning task waits on new dirt
1 of 8 streams · 2 moments
2 quotes + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #50Frustration
coins left on the counter feel open to theft
1 of 8 streams · 2 moments
2 quotes + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #51Frustration
too many customer rumors delivered at once
1 of 8 streams · 1 moment
1 quote + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #52Frustration
character cannot crouch
1 of 8 streams · 1 moment
1 quote + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #53Frustration
mine is a long walk from the shop
1 of 8 streams · 1 moment
1 quote + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #54Frustration
fixed furniture and shop layout cannot be changed
1 of 8 streams · 1 moment
1 quote + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #55Frustration
npc quest marker leads to no interaction
1 of 8 streams · 1 moment
1 quote + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #56Frustration
easy to get lost in the mine
1 of 8 streams · 1 moment
1 quote + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #57Frustration
tutorial asks for an armor rack already bought
1 of 8 streams · 1 moment
1 quote + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #58Frustration
full rack blocks restocking while customers browse
1 of 8 streams · 1 moment
1 quote + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #59Frustration
items cannot be dropped to hand to teammates
1 of 8 streams · 1 moment
1 quote + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #60Frustration
warehouse fills up quickly with gathered resources
1 of 8 streams · 1 moment
1 quote + ▶ timestamps in the full report
Suggestions and comparisons (6)
What players asked for, and which games they compared yours to.
- #63Comparison
pouring molten metal is a satisfying core step
1 of 8 streams · 1 moment
1 quote + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #61Suggestion
progression feels too fast for a long game
1 of 8 streams · 2 moments
2 quotes + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #62Suggestion
requests for customization and using crafted gear
1 of 8 streams · 1 moment
1 quote + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #64Comparison
systems and characters closely mirror tavern manager simulator
1 of 8 streams · 2 moments
2 quotes + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #65Comparison
visuals and structure resemble an earlier potion brewing sim
1 of 8 streams · 2 moments
2 quotes + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #66Comparison
order loop compared to a restaurant rush game
1 of 8 streams · 1 moment
1 quote + ▶ timestamps in the full report
What landed (15)
Moments players clearly enjoyed.
- #67Highlight
hands-on crafting process is engaging and detailed
2 of 8 streams · 5 moments
5 quotes + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #68Highlight
racks let the shop sell on its own and feel satisfying
2 of 8 streams · 3 moments
3 quotes + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #69Highlight
new crafting unlocks like bows and armor excite players
1 of 8 streams · 2 moments
2 quotes + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #70Highlight
town and hidden grove reward exploration
1 of 8 streams · 2 moments
2 quotes + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #71Highlight
shop building is charming and roomy inside and out
1 of 8 streams · 2 moments
2 quotes + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #72Highlight
early forging steps are easy to follow without english
1 of 8 streams · 1 moment
1 quote + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #73Highlight
forging and selling swords feels rewarding
1 of 8 streams · 1 moment
1 quote + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #74Highlight
relaxed pace suits interrupted play sessions
1 of 8 streams · 1 moment
1 quote + ▶ timestamps in the full report
Show all 15 moments that landedShow fewer
- #75Highlight
customers browsing racks and checking weapon condition
1 of 8 streams · 1 moment
1 quote + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #76Highlight
night mining gives a good amount of ore
1 of 8 streams · 1 moment
1 quote + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #77Highlight
the cow outside the shop is charming
1 of 8 streams · 1 moment
1 quote + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #78Highlight
hammering sound and rhythm are enjoyable
1 of 8 streams · 1 moment
1 quote + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #79Highlight
grid based furniture placement is appreciated
1 of 8 streams · 1 moment
1 quote + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #80Highlight
rare quality weapons feel rewarding
1 of 8 streams · 1 moment
1 quote + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #81Highlight
mine teleport upgrade is appreciated
1 of 8 streams · 1 moment
1 quote + ▶ timestamps in the full report
Where to submit your game next
Overheard Weekly lists the festival, showcase and fund deadlines of the next three weeks, and the unreleased games the most Twitch streamers played. Every Tuesday.
Subscribe, it's free (form on tally.so)Free. You confirm by e-mail and can unsubscribe from any issue. No open or click tracking. What's in an issue
More games we analysed

Terrible Lizards
45 problems · 15 highlights · 8 streams
platforming routes and valid landing spots are hard to read

Warhammer Survivors
45 problems · 27 highlights · 8 streams
upgrade and weapon effect texts do not explain what they change


Probably Stolen - Cyberpunk Shopkeeper Sim
36 problems · 7 highlights · 8 streams
scavenging at the dump keeps injuring the shopkeeper

Loftia
47 problems · 19 highlights · 7 streams
rules for sharing treasure hunt pickups between players unclear

Playrooms
42 problems · 22 highlights · 8 streams
picking up and depositing balls is slow before upgrades