
Playtest report preview
Ashen SwarmWhat streamers ran into on Twitch
Gothic bullet heaven roguelite where deadly sins become weapons.
We listened to 8 Twitch streams of Ashen Swarm (7h 35m in total). The problem that came up most: early runs end quickly under heavy enemy pressure, in 3 of 8 streams.
8 Twitch streams · 7h 35m analysed · French, English, Russian · analysed in the week of 19 Oct 2026 · Steam page
- Problems
- 48
- Ideas
- 6
- Highlights
- 22
Each problem, idea and highlight counts once, however often it came up. The timeline counts every moment: 131 in all.
Read what they actually saidFull report with quotes and VOD links · $49Events and lists
Featured in
Where the moments happened
Grey bars show when the streamer was talking. Each mark is one reported moment; select a type below to hide or show it.
- Stream 1, 49 min analysed: 36 problems, 6 suggestions or comparisons, 7 highlights.
- Stream 2, 46 min analysed: 3 problems, 6 highlights.
- Stream 3, 1h analysed: 9 problems, 1 highlight.
- Stream 4, 1h analysed: 10 problems, 5 suggestions or comparisons, 2 highlights.
- Stream 5, 1h analysed: 5 problems, 1 suggestion or comparison, 6 highlights.
- Stream 6, 1h analysed: nothing specific enough to report.
- Stream 7, 1h analysed: 11 problems, 3 suggestions or comparisons, 5 highlights.
- Stream 8, 1h analysed: 9 problems, 6 highlights.
In the full report each item below has the streamers' own words and a ▶ link to that minute of the Twitch recording. The # is the item's number in that report. See what a full item looks like in the sample report
Problems (48)
Bugs, confusion, frustration and the moments players gave up. The ones most streams ran into come first.
- #29Frustration
early runs end quickly under heavy enemy pressure
3 of 8 streams · 5 moments
5 quotes + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #30Frustration
default audio volume is too loud
2 of 8 streams · 4 moments
4 quotes + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #31Frustration
terrain and trees snag the player's movement
2 of 8 streams · 2 moments
2 quotes + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #3Confusion
purpose of statues and steles on the map is unclear
2 of 8 streams · 3 moments
3 quotes + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #32Frustration
player damage feels too low against enemies
2 of 8 streams · 4 moments
4 quotes + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #4Confusion
how the ultimate triggers is not understood
1 of 8 streams · 3 moments
3 quotes + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #5Confusion
systems like chests and challenges are not explained
1 of 8 streams · 2 moments
2 quotes + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #33Frustration
enemies and overall style feel generic without own identity
1 of 8 streams · 3 moments
3 quotes + ▶ timestamps in the full report
Show all 48 problemsShow fewer
- #34Frustration
sound effects feel like unfinished placeholders
1 of 8 streams · 2 moments
2 quotes + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #35Frustration
own character gets lost in crowded fights
1 of 8 streams · 2 moments
2 quotes + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #36Frustration
french localization has poor grammar and spelling
1 of 8 streams · 1 moment
1 quote + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #37Frustration
reroll button fails when no cards are left
1 of 8 streams · 1 moment
1 quote + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #1Bug
repair drone attached to character at odd angle
1 of 8 streams · 1 moment
1 quote + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #2Bug
missing word in french tutorial text
1 of 8 streams · 1 moment
1 quote + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #6Confusion
skill card wording and keywords are hard to parse
1 of 8 streams · 6 moments
6 quotes + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #7Confusion
rewards from barrels and crates are unclear
1 of 8 streams · 3 moments
3 quotes + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #8Confusion
hub objects and menu options are not self explanatory
1 of 8 streams · 2 moments
2 quotes + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #9Confusion
slowing status effect is not explained
1 of 8 streams · 2 moments
2 quotes + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #10Confusion
arrow pointing to the tempter is easy to miss
1 of 8 streams · 2 moments
2 quotes + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #11Confusion
active skill keys and the need to move are unclear early
1 of 8 streams · 1 moment
1 quote + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #12Confusion
unclear whether own fire effects hurt the player
1 of 8 streams · 1 moment
1 quote + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #13Confusion
meaning of glowing upgrade cards is not explained
1 of 8 streams · 1 moment
1 quote + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #14Confusion
raven upgrade name does not hint at its effect
1 of 8 streams · 1 moment
1 quote + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #15Confusion
unclear whether to spread or stack skill picks
1 of 8 streams · 1 moment
1 quote + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #16Confusion
enemies seem to teleport near the objective
1 of 8 streams · 1 moment
1 quote + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #17Confusion
unclear whether multiple tempter bargains can be combined
1 of 8 streams · 1 moment
1 quote + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #18Confusion
toggling auto aim shows no visible difference
1 of 8 streams · 1 moment
1 quote + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #19Confusion
unclear how to confirm an upgrade choice
1 of 8 streams · 1 moment
1 quote + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #20Confusion
pet origin and function are not explained
1 of 8 streams · 1 moment
1 quote + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #21Confusion
unclear which portal slot takes the artifact
1 of 8 streams · 1 moment
1 quote + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #22Confusion
unclear whether branch upgrades exclude each other
1 of 8 streams · 1 moment
1 quote + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #23Confusion
run length is not communicated
1 of 8 streams · 1 moment
1 quote + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #24Confusion
some events lack narrator voiceover
1 of 8 streams · 1 moment
1 quote + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #25Confusion
unclear how large the upgrade category pool is
1 of 8 streams · 1 moment
1 quote + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #26Confusion
meter at top of screen is not understood
1 of 8 streams · 1 moment
1 quote + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #27Confusion
random events are not clearly signalled
1 of 8 streams · 1 moment
1 quote + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #28Confusion
unclear that the character cannot jump
1 of 8 streams · 1 moment
1 quote + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #38Frustration
player's own ice wall blocks movement and attacks
1 of 8 streams · 2 moments
2 quotes + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #39Frustration
tempter deal texts are long and the options unappealing
1 of 8 streams · 2 moments
2 quotes + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #40Frustration
hero jump cooldown feels long
1 of 8 streams · 1 moment
1 quote + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #41Frustration
tempter damage trial is easy to fail on a first run
1 of 8 streams · 1 moment
1 quote + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #42Frustration
dense crowds block the path through the arena
1 of 8 streams · 1 moment
1 quote + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #43Frustration
early run upgrades offered late feel useless
1 of 8 streams · 1 moment
1 quote + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #44Frustration
oaths must be retaken before every expedition
1 of 8 streams · 1 moment
1 quote + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #45Frustration
tornado hazards are unwelcome
1 of 8 streams · 1 moment
1 quote + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #46Frustration
mage enemies are annoying and end the first run
1 of 8 streams · 1 moment
1 quote + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #47Frustration
only two characters available in the demo
1 of 8 streams · 1 moment
1 quote + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #48Frustration
death soon after the 13:13 collegium mark
1 of 8 streams · 1 moment
1 quote + ▶ timestamps in the full report
Suggestions and comparisons (6)
What players asked for, and which games they compared yours to.
- #49Suggestion
controller support is wanted
2 of 8 streams · 2 moments
2 quotes + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #53Comparison
game compared to megabonk and other roguelike survivor titles
2 of 8 streams · 8 moments
8 quotes + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #50Suggestion
no minimap makes arena navigation hard
1 of 8 streams · 3 moments
3 quotes + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #51Suggestion
no camera invert or in-run camera settings
1 of 8 streams · 3 moments
3 quotes + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #52Suggestion
player wants a dodge move
1 of 8 streams · 1 moment
1 quote + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #54Comparison
hub character reminds of hades
1 of 8 streams · 1 moment
1 quote + ▶ timestamps in the full report
What landed (22)
Moments players clearly enjoyed.
- #55Highlight
visual art style is well liked
4 of 8 streams · 4 moments
4 quotes + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #56Highlight
crow companion that follows and collects pickups is loved
3 of 8 streams · 4 moments
4 quotes + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #57Highlight
movement speed upgrades feel good
2 of 8 streams · 3 moments
3 quotes + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #58Highlight
burn upgrades are appealing picks
2 of 8 streams · 2 moments
2 quotes + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #59Highlight
skill effects like ice wall and damage link feel satisfying
1 of 8 streams · 1 moment
1 quote + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #60Highlight
weaver web hitting many enemies at once feels strong
1 of 8 streams · 1 moment
1 quote + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #61Highlight
orbiting spark skill is a favourite pick
1 of 8 streams · 2 moments
2 quotes + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #62Highlight
pig ability is funny and enjoyed
1 of 8 streams · 2 moments
2 quotes + ▶ timestamps in the full report
Show all 22 moments that landedShow fewer
- #63Highlight
menu music and atmosphere make a good first impression
1 of 8 streams · 1 moment
1 quote + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #64Highlight
longer pickup range upgrade feels good
1 of 8 streams · 1 moment
1 quote + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #65Highlight
large enemy waves are exciting
1 of 8 streams · 1 moment
1 quote + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #66Highlight
carpet bombing skill feels good
1 of 8 streams · 1 moment
1 quote + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #67Highlight
core run and shoot loop works well
1 of 8 streams · 1 moment
1 quote + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #68Highlight
meta upgrade choices after death look appealing
1 of 8 streams · 1 moment
1 quote + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #69Highlight
story encounters continuing across runs spark interest
1 of 8 streams · 1 moment
1 quote + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #70Highlight
upgrades carrying over to new characters is appreciated
1 of 8 streams · 1 moment
1 quote + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #71Highlight
voiced narration is enjoyed
1 of 8 streams · 1 moment
1 quote + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #72Highlight
sin themed upgrade categories are liked
1 of 8 streams · 1 moment
1 quote + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #73Highlight
unlocking a new hero eases roster worries
1 of 8 streams · 1 moment
1 quote + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #74Highlight
corruption mode alternate abilities are liked
1 of 8 streams · 1 moment
1 quote + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #75Highlight
pride sin weapon feels good
1 of 8 streams · 1 moment
1 quote + ▶ timestamps in the full report - #76Highlight
statues in the level impress
1 of 8 streams · 1 moment
1 quote + ▶ timestamps in the full report
Where to submit your game next
Overheard Weekly lists the festival, showcase and fund deadlines of the next three weeks, and the unreleased games the most Twitch streamers played. Every Tuesday.
Subscribe, it's free (form on tally.so)Free. You confirm by e-mail and can unsubscribe from any issue. No open or click tracking. What's in an issue
More games we analysed

Terrible Lizards
45 problems · 15 highlights · 8 streams
platforming routes and valid landing spots are hard to read

Warhammer Survivors
45 problems · 27 highlights · 8 streams
upgrade and weapon effect texts do not explain what they change


Probably Stolen - Cyberpunk Shopkeeper Sim
36 problems · 7 highlights · 8 streams
scavenging at the dump keeps injuring the shopkeeper

Loftia
47 problems · 19 highlights · 7 streams
rules for sharing treasure hunt pickups between players unclear

Playrooms
42 problems · 22 highlights · 8 streams
picking up and depositing balls is slow before upgrades